Golden Fonseca Investments LLC

oran I KI I Lyorls I J’ohnson PA

Nicole C. Canha
Jason P. Del Rosso
Andrea D. Saunders
Daren J. Dorminy United States Patent and Trademark Office
Frank Garcia
Law Office 117
James Madison Building – East Wing
Ingrid Gonzalez Concourse Level
Georgia E. Higgins 600 Dulany Street
Alexandria, Virginia 22313
Scott E. Johnson

Nathan J. Kaplan RE:
James F. Kidd

Clinton C. Lyons, Jr.

Brian J. Moran

Chris R. Parkinson Serial No.: 76719658
David A. Ruiz
Dear Ms. Saunders:

The purpose of this letter is to respond to the Office Action issued on the
Of Counsel
above-referenced trademark application on September 20, 2016. The issues
Michael A. Tessitore raised in the Office Action will be addressed separately below.


We agree to add the following Disclaimer language to the application:

No claim is made to the exclusive right to use
“ORLANDO” and “EST. 2016″ and “SOCCER PUB &
GRILL” apart from the mark as shown.


We agree with the suggested revisions to the Description of the Mark and
request that the Description of the Mark be revised accordingly so that it reads
as follows:

The mark consists of the word ORLANDO inside the
band ofa circle with scalloped edges; LION’S PRIDE
below going across the width of the circle with
extended lines coming from the “L”; EST. 2016 below

Respond to: PO Box 472, Orlando, FL 32802-0472
111 N. Orange Ave., Suite 900, Orlando, FL 32801-2361 7850 NW. 146 Street, Suite 506, Miami Lakes, FL 33016
Ph: 407.841.4141 I Fax: 407.841.4148 Ph: 305.821.6655 l Fax: 305.821.6699
Andrea D. Saunders
March 17, 2017
Page 2

with horizontal lines on each side, SOCCER PUB &
GRILL below on the inside band of the circle, and the
words THIS IS OUR PLACE to the right on the
outside of the circle. ,


The Office Action cites two (2) registered trademarks:

3′:‘ I

, Reg. No. 4266434 (word and design) and LION’S PRIDE
(word mark), Reg. No. 3895172(“Koval’s marks”) as being confusingly similarto
PLACE and Design (“Applicant’s mark”).

A. Lack of Use in Interstate Commerce

The above-referenced registered marks are registered in Class 33 for
“whiskey” and are owned by Koval Inc. (“Koval”), a whiskey distillery company in
Chicago, Illinois. Based on our review of Koval’s website, it appears that Koval
is no longer using LION’S PRIDE for its whiskey products. Attached as Exhibit
“A” is the search result for “lion’s pride” on Koval’s website. The only result that
appeared is “Rye recipes” which refers to “Lion’s Breath”, n_ot LION’S PRIDE.

B. Marks are dissimilar

Applicant’s mark contains additional elements that clearly distinguish it
from Koval’s marks. Applicant concedes that some of the words contained in its
mark are merely descriptive (i.e., ORLANDO SOCCER PUB & GRILL EST.
2016). However, THIS IS OUR PLACE is not merely descriptive. Further, Koval’s
word and design mark contains a color image of the head of a lion. No lion
image appears in the Applican’ts mark. Instead, it includes a circle with
scalloped edges design. The circle with scalloped edges design and THIS IS
OUR PLACE additional wording clearly differentiates Applicant’s mark from
Koval’s marks. According to TMEP §1207.01(c)(ii) marks must be considered in
their entireties and comparison of composite marks must be done on a case-by-
case basis. See Jack Wolfskin Ausrustung Fur Draussen GmbH & Co. KGAA v.
Andrea D. Saunders
March 17, 2017
Page 3

New Millennium Sports, S.L.U., 797 F.3d 1363, 1371, 116 USPQ2d 1129, 1134
(Fed. Cir. 2015) (holding that Board finding lacked substantial evidence for
minimizing the literal element in composite mark); Massey Junior Call, Inc. v.
Fashion Inst. of Tech., 492 F.2d 1399, 1402, 181 USPQ 272, 273-74 (C.C.P.A.
1974) (holding that FIA FASHION INSTITUTE OF AMERICA and Design for
educational services, namely, offering courses in fashion, merchandising and
retailing and FIT design mark for educational services at the college level, not
likely to cause confusion; In re Covalinski, 113 USPQZd 1166 (TTAB 2014)
(holding confusion unlikely between REDNECK RACEGIRL and design of large,
double-letter RR configuration and registered mark RACEGIRL, even when used
on in-part identical goods); In re White Rock Distilleries Inc., 92 USPQZd 1282
(TTAB 2009) (holding VOLTA for vodka infused with caffeine, and TERZA
VOLTA and vine shoot design for wines, not likely to cause confusion).

Finally, in In re Electrolyte Labs. Inc, 929 F.2d 645, 647, 16 USPQZd
1239, 1240 (Fed. Cir. 1990). the Federal Circuit Court of Appeal stated that
“[t]here is no general rule as to whether letters or designs will dominate in
composite marks; nor is the dominance of letters or design dispositive of the
issue.” Thus, Applicant’s mark should not be deemed confusingly similar to
Koval’s marks simply because each of the marks contain the words LION’S

Based on the above, we respectfully request that the confusingly similar
determination be withdrawn. Thank you for your attention to this matter. Should
you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me.

Si e y,

Scott E. Johnson

KOVAL Distillery – Search Page 1 of 1


Search Keywordzi lion’s pride Search

Search for:

©All words OAny words OExact Phrase

Ordering: Newest First

Search Only:

[:1 Catego ri es [:| Co nt ac ts DA rt ic le s E] Ne ws Fe ed s D We b Li nk s

Totalzgi lresults found. Display# 20 ,v

Ry e Re ci pe s (/ ne ws it e/ 11 0- en g| is h/ re ci pe s/ 18 0- ry e- re ci pe s)

Posted in Recipes

Angostura Bitters Stir, strain into a coc kta il gla ss, and gar nis h wit h a lem on twi st. Lio n’s Bre ath Lau –

ren Berg, ICl, Brooklyn, NY 3 oz KOVAL Rye Whiskey 1-
¢ search…

Newsletter Sign Up

(/newsite/de/) 15E(Inewsite/component/search/?searchword=lion%27s%

n htt ://www.facebook.c m/k vald isti lle 7r f=b rt ’ (ht tps ?/t wit tgr .co m/k ova ldi sti |le m?
© 2017 KOVAL INC

http://www.kova1-distillery .co m/n ews ite /co mpo nen t/s ear chl ?se arc hwo rd= 1io n‘s %20 pri de& s.. . 3/7/201 7
KOVAL Distillery – Rye Recipes Page 1 of 3



KOVAL House Manhattan Lion’s Breath

KOVAL Staff Favorite, Chicago, IL Lauren Berg, lCl, Brooklyn, NY

2 oz KOVAL Rye Whiskey 3 oz KOVAL Rye Whiskey

1/2 oz Dolin Dry Vermouth 1-2 tsp Anise simple syrup to taste

1/2 oz KOVAL Rose Hip Liqueur 1 dash Bitters

2 Dashes Angostura Bitters Stir, strain into a rocks glass,
and garnish with a large lemon peel.
. _ _ . *To make anise simple syrup:
Stir, strain Into a cocktail glass,
‘ _ . Bring fresh anise – including blossoms,
and garnish With a lemon tWIst.
leaves, and stems – to a boil with equal
parts water and sugar. Cool and strain.

The High Ryes Steph’s Sour

Alex Uribe, Bistro Campagne, Chicago, IL Scot Mattox, Iris, New Orleans, LA

http://www.koval— 1 10-english/recipes/1 80-rye-recipes 3/7/2017
KOVAL Distillery – Rye Recipes Page 2 of 3

KOVAL Rye Whiskey KOVAL Rye Whiskey

North Shore Aquavit KOVAL Chrysanthemum &
KOVAL Caraway Liqueur

Lemon juice
Honey Syrup

_ I Simple syrup
Bittercube Orange Bitters

6 Drops Dutch’s Colonial Bitters
Shake, Strain into a chilled rocks glass
and garnish with a lemon twist.
1 Barspoon Egg white

Dry shake the egg white. Combine all ingredi-
ents in a mixing glass filled with ice. Shake,
strain over ice into a rocks glass. Garnish
_ with a rinsed Luxardo cherry.

Old Fashioned Pride

Depalma’s Downtown, Athens, GA

KOVAL Rye Whiskey 1 0-eng1ish/recipes/1 80-rye—recipes 3/7/201 7
KOVAL Distillery – Rye Recipes Page 3 of 3

1 tsp Brown Sugar

3 Dashes Bitters


Orange Wedge

Muddle cherry, orange, sugar and bitters.
Add ice and liquors, stir. Garnish with a lem-
on twist.

Q search…

Newsletter Sign Up

– (Inewsite/del) (Inewsite/110-english/recipes/180-rye-recipes)

n (https://www,fgcebogk,ggm/kovaIdistiIlery?ref=pr If), (

© 2017 KOVAL INC

http :// 1 10-english/recipes/1 80-rye-recipes 3/7/2017